The infamous Porsche hit-and-run incident in Pune had taken the media by storm a couple of months ago. While it spurred a lot of backlash and controversy, there were major forces at play, including the local MLA, that tried their best to fabricate or destroy any evidence that could be used to incriminate the teenager.
The most recent update on this case seems to be that the offender is being denied admission to colleges due to this ongoing criminal case. In all likelihood though, he is going to walk away freely, given the power and influence his family wields.
This goes on to show just how broken law and justice is in our country. And this is only one of the countless instances of such blatant disregard for the law. We have witnessed time and again that the upper echelon can do as they please, without facing any major consequences for their actions. Coming from an affluent background does have its advantages, but being immune to the law shouldn't be one.
Who, then, is to be blamed for this? The criminal? Maybe. A wise man once said, 'Criminal toh crime karega hi. Tum satark kyu nahi rehte. Ab tum apni body leke bahar ghumoge, toh criminal kaat hi dega na.'
On a serious note though, this is a recurring theme we keep seeing on a daily basis. The RG Kar rape case is yet another monstrosity that shocked the entire nation. It was beyond brutal, but what's worse is that the goons were backed by certain political leaders. Such levels of fuckery simply aren't possible without insider help.
Are the law enforcers and government officials at fault then? Or does this run deeper, indicating a fundamental systemic problem? What I've mentioned are but a few cherry-picked examples, out of potentially thousands. However, I don't like ranting without offering a way out, so what can be done to improve this shit show?
Maybe, just maybe, let's assume that the justice system is corrupt beyond repair, that all law enforcers are immoral. Whether we like it or not, none of it is in our control. Sure, you could try and bring about reforms in the system, but the reality is, your efforts will mostly be in vain.
What then, can be done, without expecting the above to change? You change yourself, and if possible, the people around you. That's it.
Now you'd be thinking what the hell am I talking about. Surely you aren't at all like the people mentioned above. Even comparing yourself to these idiots may sound insulting. But let's not forget that in their own minds, most criminals, and even terrorists, are doing the right thing.
In reality, there are more people in our society with a messed up moral compass than we'd like to admit. Even those in our own social circles maybe. How can this be fixed, if at all?
The first thing we need to accept is - in a country of over a billion people, there are bound to be such miscreants roaming the streets freely. We do not live in a utopian world, and never will. The darkest parts of the darkest corners of our minds can, and do shape our actions to a certain extent. This is fundamental to humans, and isn't going away anytime soon. The best that can be done to keep it in check is to impose punishments so terrifying that people start fearing the consequences.
But that would still leave the root cause unaddressed, which is the lack of having a strong moral system. Few of us may excel in this regard, but most people, including me, tend to hover in some sort of grey area, which is far from evil, but not quite virtuous either. While this isn't a bad thing, there's definitely a lot of room for improvement.
Enter Stoicism. In case you're new to this philosophy, I urge you to delve deeper. You may even find that you've already been following some of it unknowingly. Why bother with it though? Because unlike most other schools of thought, it is a sensible, no-bullshit manual for navigating through life.
There's a lot to be unpacked with this philosophy, most of which is beyond the scope of this post, but I'd like to touch upon a few core tenets here.
The first thing you need to understand is the dichotomy of control, which tells us to focus on the things we can control, and let go of the things we cannot. You hold little to no power over how other people act, what governments do, and even what happens to you or your body. However, you can control how you react to these things. Basically, we all have free will.
Secondly, Stoicism is largely unconcerned with the existence of God/s. Simply put, if Gods exist and they care about how you lived, you'll get rewarded for leading a virtuous life. If they do not exist, you will still have lived a great life anyway. Win-win either way.
Then there are the four pillars of Stoicism - wisdom, courage, justice and temperance. The first three are pretty obvious, but the last one I'd like to talk about.
Temperance, as the name suggests, is all about moderation. It's about avoiding extremes, and striking a balance between pleasure and pain to avoid falling prey to vices like greed and jealousy. This is a tough one to actually follow, but it's fundamental to Stoicism.
Now comes the most important part. Prosoche. The essence of this word is being attentive or vigilant, to act with intent. This is required to make Stoicism a way of life, and not just another pedantic philosophy.
Prosoche means to be rooted in the present, not the past or future. To be conscious of every thought, word and action. This may sound straightforward, but it is difficult to implement on a daily basis.
The goal isn't perfection, even though it is ideal. Only sages can achieve true eudaimonia, which is a state of flourishing or happiness. For us mere mortals, it's best to accept that Stoicism isn't some end goal that can be achieved, but a constant journey of introspection and self-improvement.
I've started practicing prosoche (which makes me a 'prokopton'), and let me tell you it is a constant uphill climb. I'm planning to cover this in greater depth in a future, more actionable post.
For those looking to explore further, I'd suggest picking up Meditations by Marcus Aurelius or The Enchiridion of Epictetus. You can also listen to the Good Fortune podcast, which draws more parallels to modern day life.
Also, when I say change, I don't just mean adopting this mindset. It's about living with intent, to do whatever it takes to protect you and your loved ones. It could be learning self-defense or basic survival skills, carrying a weapon, or educating yourself on the law. Anything that helps you stay safe and tough to mess with. Basically, you shouldn't be a victim of your circumstances.
I'm aware that I didn't cover this subject from enough aspects, but in all fairness, the topics involved have enough depth to justify an entire blog series. This has already turned out to be much longer than expected, in fact, 4x longer than the essay written by that Porsche brat, so kudos to you if you made it all the way through.
Ultimately, things are bound to change if enough people (especially those in positions of power) recognize and live by these ideas diligently.
It is not an easy task to get this through the thick skulls of those who actually need to hear this, but we can still do our part first before preaching to others. I realize the discussion has been rather grim so far, so I'll end this on a more positive note. Amor fati.